Behold the Power of Tags

By leelefever on February 15, 2005 - 6:39pm.

You've likely heard of "The Gates", an art installation in Central Park by the Christo and Jeanne-Claude.

The other night, I thought about how I would be taking a bunch of photos if I were there. Then I thought- I bet there are some good ones, let's check Flickr". I searched for the tag "thegates" and found over 1200 photos of the art installation. It took maybe 10 seconds for me to find them. It was overwhelming, but really satisfying too.

Today there are over 2000 photos with that tag. I'm not sure it could get any easier, unless some sort of rating system showed me the best of the 2000 as deemed by viewers.

Technorati Tags: tags, thegates, nyc

Behold the Power of Tags

I agree that the shear number of these is overwhelming, but I would more than one way to slice up the images than just what was "best". Personally, I find what I consider "best" is very different than what the majority of people consider best.

And this makes me think about why people are complaining that folksonomies don't help us find worthwhile information. Right now, tags tend toward descriptions of attributes and less so toward descriptions of quality:

In a wholly unscientific comparison, here is a sample of tags from the top 150:

art (22033), beach (21421), green (10574), kids (9437), sunset (15860), zoo (6156)

Looking through the list, I did not find tags that seem to describe the quality of the photo or of the subject. Searching only on tags (not titles or descriptions), i threw a few random quality descriptions in:

cute (3821)
beautiful (942)
pretty (770)
bad (663)
good (605)
boring (210)
interesting (103)
quality (96)
unusual (36)
excellent (16)
dull (13)
uninteresting (1)
uncreative (0)

So not only are people bad at tagging, they seem to be really bad at using quality descriptions in their tags.

Something that might be valuable, is a way for other to add tags to your photos/links/documents. The caveat here is that when we can tag other peoples "property" some will see it as a form of graffiti.

Another alternative is that tags I add to other people's tags are seen only by me and by those in my network. Maybe it could be something as simple as a tag that recommends the resource to people in my network. It could be an additional photostream that could introduce me to people at the fringe or outside my immediate network.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

About This Blog

We've been serving up fresh content here since 2003. Lately we're most excited about making Paperworks videos, Our Video Store, being small, simplicity and disruption of all sorts.

Have a suggestion? Tell us about it, please.

Subscribe... It's Fun!

Use an RSS Reader


Subscribe in Bloglines Add to Google Reader or Homepage


What's RSS?

Enter your email address:

Comments

Details, Details

Creative Commons LicenseLicensed
powered
E-junkie Shopping Cart and Digital Delivery Monetized

The Common Craft name and logo are trademarks of Common Craft, LLC. Copyright ©2003-2007. All blog posts and Common Craft Show videos are Creative Commons licensed.